Bonbon Sprout
Uncommon

In addition to their spherical shape these sprouts have a vague chocolate flavor great for sauces.

Broomstick Twigs
Common

A small bundle of twigs from a witch's broomstick.

Brown Clay Tile
Uncommon

A sturdy clay tile, with a basic pattern on it.

Carrot
Uncommon

A favorite of rabbits everywhere. Source: Farm Knoll

Cucumber
Uncommon

These go great with vinegar. Source: Farm Knoll

Dark Torch
Uncommon

This is a torch enchanted for dark arts rituals, and the flame generally burns purple or green.

Flint Arrowhead
Common

This is a hand-hewn flint arrowhead that was likely at the tip of an arrow or spear at one time.

Ghoul Key
Common

This key looks like it's been handled by the undead fairly recently.

Iron Bolt
Common

This is a very sturdy bolt, made of iron.

Lettuce
Common

Crunchy lettuce goes great in salads and sandwiches. Source: Farm Knoll

Onion
Common

These always make us cry... Source: Farm Knoll

Palm Seed
Common

A palm frond could sprout from this seed, theoretically anyway.

Peas
Uncommon

These would make a great soup! Source: Farm Knoll

Pigeon Feather
Common

Collect enough of these feathers and you could make a set of wings and fly too close to the sun and then plummet to your death.

Pokeweed
Ultra-Rare

It's sharp, what did you expect? Source: Farm Knoll

Pumpkin
Rare

These would make a really nice spiced latte. Source: Farm Knoll

Squash
Common

Squish, squash, squoosh. Source: Farm Knoll

Watermelon
Rare

This sweet treat is always refreshing.

White Candle
Common

This candle is made of white wax, and looks to only have been lit once or twice.