Peach
Common

Beautiful peaches, peaches for me. Source: Wild Knoll

Pepper
Common

This is great as a spice, and as an ingredient in joke sneeze powder.

Pigeon Feather
Common

Collect enough of these feathers and you could make a set of wings and fly too close to the sun and then plummet to your death.

Pink Crisp Apple
Common

They say if you eat one of these, then one day you'll be a doctor. Source: Wild Knoll

Pink Glass Shards
Common

These shards of glass are a curious pink color.

Pixie Skull
Rare

You wonder where the rest of this very tiny skeleton ended up, leaving behind only the head.

Pixie Wings
Rare

These wings were left behind by a deceased pixie, and still retain a faint glow.

Poisoned Tankard
Common

This tankard has some unpleasant green stains on it.

Red Glass Shards
Common

Apparently someone saw red, and then smashed whatever this was.

Red Yarn Ball
Common

This yarn is finely woven and stained with Indian Paintbrush pigment to be bright red.

Rotting Boards
Common

These boards have been sitting somewhere damp for a long time and are infested with fungus and rot.

Rusty Fish Hook
Common

There's something particularly unpleasant about this rusty fish hook.

Rusty Iron Spring
Common

This spring, while once clearly finely made and very springy, is now rusted and probably unreliable.

Sapphire
Ultra-Rare

One of the greatest of he precious gems, sapphires reportedly are most useful in spells and magic relating to stars, the heavens, and divining the future.

Scarlet Snipe Feather
Rare

The feathers of the scarlet snipe are a rarified commodity.

Seafoam Shell
Uncommon

This shell is from the sea, but also happens to be a seafoam color.

Shaggy Gourd
Uncommon

Everyone's favorite fall food! Source: Wild Knoll

Shambling Algae
Uncommon

Oh when this blooms, it's a sight to behold! It also appears to move on its own sometimes, watch out. Source: Wild Knoll

Silver Jingle Bell
Common

Without extensive testing, it's hard to say if this bell will jingle all the way or only part of the way.

Slime Mold
Common

Various slime molds infest the dungeons and dark places of the world. This one is green.

Sulfur
Common

This strange-smelling mineral has found uses in things flammable, corrosive, or various items in necromancy and swamp magic.

Vampire Bat Wing
Rare

A vampire bat passed away and this is one of the wings left behind.

Voodoo Pick
Rare

When pins won't do the trick, a voodoo pick is a useful item in dark magic.

Vulture Claw Charm
Uncommon

This charm made from a vulture claw has strange writing on it, which you cannot read.

Zinc
Rare

A lustrous metal, zinc is a powerful aid in spells relating to freezing and cold.