Pest Collard
Rare

Annoying, but delicious Source: Farm Knoll

Pigeon Bones
Common

As with most birds, these pigeon bones are hollow.

Pigeon Feather
Common

Collect enough of these feathers and you could make a set of wings and fly too close to the sun and then plummet to your death.

Pine Dreamcatcher
Rare

You check this dreamcatcher but there don't seem to be any dreams caught in it. Yet.

Pineapple
Rare

More like Fineapple, am I right? Source: Farm Knoll

Pink Crisp Apple
Common

They say if you eat one of these, then one day you'll be a doctor. Source: Wild Knoll

Pixie Skull
Rare

You wonder where the rest of this very tiny skeleton ended up, leaving behind only the head.

Pixie Torch
Rare

This tiny torch was crafted and meant to be carried by a pixie.

Poisoned Tankard
Common

This tankard has some unpleasant green stains on it.

Potato
Common

PO-TAT-TOE. Source: Farm Knoll

Potted Vine
Uncommon

There's no way to tell what kind of vine this is until you water it and give it some sunlight.

Puce Yarn
Common

You are already imagining all the craft projects you could be doing with this puce yarn.

Pumpkin
Rare

These would make a really nice spiced latte. Source: Farm Knoll

Purple Cabbage
Uncommon

Like regular cabbage, but purpler. Source: Farm Knoll

Rainbow Sprite Powder
Uncommon

This powder is a residue leftover from Rainbow Sprites as they frolic in the forest.

Red Glass Shards
Common

Apparently someone saw red, and then smashed whatever this was.

Red Silk Scarf
Uncommon

This silk was dyed red with essence of the madder plant.

Rock Tortoise Shell
Rare

Known for their impervious qualities, rock tortoise shells in days of yore were used to create dragon-fire-proof shields.

Rotten Jackalope Eggs
Common

These jackalope eggs do not smell good.

Sage Thistle
Common

When ground up a certain way, this make a very nice spice. Source: Wild Knoll

Salt
Common

This is refined salt crystals. Yum!

Salt Crystals
Common

This is the crude beginning of table salt. Source: Mine

Scarlet Snipe Feather
Rare

The feathers of the scarlet snipe are a rarified commodity.

Seafoam Shell
Uncommon

This shell is from the sea, but also happens to be a seafoam color.

Shaggy Gourd
Uncommon

Everyone's favorite fall food! Source: Wild Knoll

Shoelaces
Uncommon

These laces are made of leather and would be great for lacing not only shoes but also bodices, jerkins, or other items that need to be cinched.

Silver Berry
Rare

Why did they name them Silver Berries when they are clearly red? We'll never know.

Silver Candlestick
Rare

This silver candlestick is only slightly tarnished and would go well in any bedroom or dinner setting.

Silver Jingle Bell
Common

Without extensive testing, it's hard to say if this bell will jingle all the way or only part of the way.

Slate
Uncommon

A stone excellent for flagstones and building.

Slime Mold
Common

Various slime molds infest the dungeons and dark places of the world. This one is green.

Spider Charm
Common

Crafted by Vincent Montague, this charm will hypnotize a baby spider long enough to allow harmless interaction.

Spider Fang
Common

A large Fang from a Large Spider.

Squash
Common

Squish, squash, squoosh. Source: Farm Knoll

Strange Root
Rare

What is this the root of? Hopefully not all evil... Source: Farm Knoll

Straw Bundle
Common

How much straw goes into a bundle varies from country to country. This bundle feels just right to you.

Sugar Cane
Common

This is the crude beginning of sugar. Source: Wild Knoll

Tallow Soap
Common

This soap smells musky and produces a fine lather.

Tea Melon
Uncommon

These are way better than cantaloupe. Source: Wild Knoll

Tempest Stone
Ultra-Rare

Crafted by astropaths and astrologists, tempest stones hold hidden powers relating to the stars and weather.

Thrown Horseshoe
Common

This horseshoe is considered unlucky, as it was thrown by a horse at some point.

Tin Bell
Common

This bell makes a tinny sound.

Tin Pegs
Uncommon

The benefit of tin pegs is that they are lightweight. The downside is that they are tin.

Tomato
Common

Some people like these in sandwiches, and they are wrong. Source: Farm Knoll

Torn Olaf's Flyer
Common

This flyer has been ripped unceremoniously from a set of nails, and it's tattered at the top.

Unholy Sheet Music
Uncommon

This piece of sheet music glows with a reddish light, and you get the feeling you don't want to hear the music on it.

Voodoo Pick
Rare

When pins won't do the trick, a voodoo pick is a useful item in dark magic.

Watermelon
Rare

This sweet treat is always refreshing.

Werecat Eye
Ultra-Rare

The piercing eye of a werecat.

Wheat
Common

This is a very useful grain!