Broomstick Twigs
Common

A small bundle of twigs from a witch's broomstick.

Jackalope Eggs
Common

For a creature that is part jackrabbit and part antelope, these eggs look surprisingly normal.

Thrown Horseshoe
Common

This horseshoe is considered unlucky, as it was thrown by a horse at some point.

Iron Fork
Common

This fork has 4 tines, and would be perfect for skewering food or perhaps being wielded by a very tiny demon.

Seafoam Shell
Uncommon

This shell is from the sea, but also happens to be a seafoam color.

Angel Harp
Ultra-Rare

Angels make the finest harps, and then leave them behind when they decide to ditch their halos for horns.

Red Silk Scarf
Uncommon

This silk was dyed red with essence of the madder plant.

Garlic
Common

Your breath will stink but you're safe from dracula, so win some lose some. Source: Farm Knoll

Unholy Sheet Music
Uncommon

This piece of sheet music glows with a reddish light, and you get the feeling you don't want to hear the music on it.

Aluminum Plating
Uncommon

This aluminum plating could be useful in making armor or repairing various metal household objects.

Slime Mold
Common

Various slime molds infest the dungeons and dark places of the world. This one is green.

Pigeon Feather
Common

Collect enough of these feathers and you could make a set of wings and fly too close to the sun and then plummet to your death.

Oak Bead
Common

This oak bead looks very old, and you wonder what civilization produced it.

Illegible Pages
Common

These pages are scrawled with maddeningly illegible writing.

Human Molar
Uncommon

You wonder if the owner of this molar is still alive, and if so, whether they are missing it.

Poisoned Tankard
Common

This tankard has some unpleasant green stains on it.

Ice Barnacle Resin
Uncommon

This resin is blue, and very sticky.

Oak Bowl
Common

This bowl was hand-carved from a solid piece of oak.

White Candle
Common

This candle is made of white wax, and looks to only have been lit once or twice.

Ivory Thread
Uncommon

This ivory thread is pure white and has a lot of tensile strength to it.

Iron Tacks
Uncommon

They're pretty tacky.

Hellhound Claw
Rare

Generally attempting to retrieve the claw of a hellhound is a terrible idea, making them somewhat rarified.

Brass Bolt
Common

Overshadowed by their iron and steel cousins, bolts made of brass still maintain a healthy presence in the steampunk construction market.

Grass Screen
Uncommon

A fine grass screen, useful for catching fish or preventing debris from blowing into your house.

Hemp Twine
Common

Someone took their time weaving this sturdy hemp twine.